Friday, November 20, 2026

Understanding China. Seeing what’s next.

Understanding China. Seeing what’s next.

The electric saws buzzed downstairs. Then came the smell of carrot soup

The high-profile murder trial of Hong Kong socialite Abby Choi entered its third week, with prosecutors calling key witnesses to testify about the gruesome details uncovered at the Lung Mei Village ground-floor unit.

Tso Chin-to, who lived directly above the crime scene, took the witness stand to recount the unsettling events leading up to the gruesome discovery. Tso testified that in the days before the incident, he noticed the windows of the apartment below had been sealed off with black materials. On the afternoon of the incident, he saw two beige seven-seater vans parked outside the building.

Shortly after, he heard shuffling noises from downstairs, followed by the chilling sounds of impacts and electric saws. The noise lasted for about 20 to 30 minutes, though the neighbor noted he never heard any cries for help or human voices.

邻居庭审证言引发关注:案件细节在法庭对质中现原形

As the sounds faded, Tso recalled smelling a strong aroma of a traditional Chinese pork bone and vegetable soup wafting up from below—so pungent that it prompted him to order takeout instead. During cross-examination, defense attorneys challenged this olfactory memory, suggesting it might have been implanted by subsequent media coverage, an admission Tso partially conceded.

The prosecution also summoned a saleswoman from a local kitchenware shop. She testified that in early February last year, an elderly, white-haired customer walked into her store specifically asking for a meat grinder. The man eventually purchased an Italian-made meat grinder, alongside a large stockpot, cutting boards, and other culinary tools totaling HK$9,153, which was discounted to HK$8,700.

Prosecutors played closed-circuit television footage in the courtroom, clearly showing Kwong Kau—the victim’s former father-in-law and one of the defendants—inside the store. A younger man was seen assisting with the transport of the equipment. According to the witness, Kwong also inquired about heavy-duty machinery capable of pulverizing bones and whether such devices could grind down an entire skeletal frame. Upon learning that industrial bone-crushing equipment would cost around HK$35,000, Kwong and his companion deemed it too expensive and abandoned the idea.

During cross-examination, defense lawyers argued that the long lapse in time would inevitably taint the witness’s memory of the exact conversation. However, the store clerk firmly reiterated that Kwong had indeed made the inquiries.

To date, the three defendants—Anthony Kwong, Kwong Kau, and Alex Kwong—have all pleaded not guilty to murder charges. The trial proceedings are ongoing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *